Search this Site

Monday, July 26, 2010

Top 10 most hated, and least admired US companies for 2010

I have been reading many survey results about America's least admired companies for 2010. Results have been published in the internet and in business magazines. These surveys tell which company in the US have been voted for this year's worst companies. Please note that these surveys are NOT about the worst companies to work for, but how these companies were evaluated based on the criteria of judging which I will discuss it shortly.

You can find some of these reports from here and here and here and here.


The Results


To give you an idea, here's the survey results that have been published from Fortune, Huffington Post, WallSt, and Consumerist. I decided to put them how they rank those companies and let's see how they fare with one another.

Rank       Fortune                     Huffington WallST Consumerist
_________________________________________________________________________
1              Dillard's                        Freddi Mac           AIG                   Comcast
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2               PDVA                       AIG                    United Airlines     Ticketmaster
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3              Nortel Networks          Fannie Mae           Level 3               Cash4Gold
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4              Sears Holdings            Citigroup              Hertz               Bank of America
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5              Citigroup                    Goldman Sachs      Citigroup
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6              United Airlines            Chrysler                K-Mart
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7              Boyd Gaming             General Motors       Blackwater
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8              Penn National            JP Morgan             Dell
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9               Dollar Stores              Bank of America      Abercrombie
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
10             Health Net                Delta                      Chrysler
_________________________________________________________________________

How I read the data

From the list, there are at least 6 companies that have been independently and repeatedly voted more than once. These companies didn't appear among the top 3 list. Comcast which voted by Consumerist as the Worst Company appeared only once:

Citigroup                          3 times
United Airlines                2 times
AIG                                 2 times
Bank of America              2 times
Chrysler                           2 times
Sears Holdings/K-Mart   2 times

As you have noticed, most of the survey results do not agree but it doesn't mean it's not credible. Surveys were taken obviously on different vantage points and different audience as well. The differences outweighed similarities. Only Citigroup was voted three times from the first 3 survey results but only appeared on the 4th or 5th spot. United Airlines, AIG, Bank of America, Chrysler, and K-Mart which is part of Sears Holdings, where voted twice by the four survey reports.

Another difference was how the surveys titled their respective reports. For instance, Fortune Magazine used the term, "Least Admired" while WallSt used the term "Most Hated". The former, although it may carry the same effect or gravity, was least offensive while the latter was loaded with emotional overtones. Huffington Post report used the term, "Least Liked" which is equally passive for a description, while Consumerist used the superlative word "Worst" to describe its number one pick.


Criteria for Judging

How are these companies were chosen in the first place? Criteria for judging in itself, is another issue. In fact, these surveys approach the situation differently. Although they may differ slightly with respect to criteria for judging, most surveys apply using the following standard rules:

  1. Customer satisfaction level. These level figures are being analized from different sources such as but not limite to Consumer Reports, JD Power, MSN/Zogby Poll, Vanno, etc.  For instance, AIG has a satisfactory level as follows: Extremely Satisfied: 19%, Very Satisfied: 10%, Somewhat Satisfied: 10% , Unsatisfied: 10%, Very Unsatisfied: 51%.
  2. Employee Impressions. It simply answer the question, "How do you rate the company."
  3. Investment value over a specific period. Another criterion that was put into consideration is the return to shareholders over a one-year period up to five-year period and how data are being compared to the broad market. It answer the question, "How much ROI over a certain period."
  4. How taxpayers view the company. For instance, Bank of America have received USD$45 Billion bailouts being doled out using taxpayers' money for the last few years. 
  5. Brand value. Brand valuation changes mainly from Corebrands, Interbrand, Brand Z.
  6. Executive response. It is important to note that Hays Group, the third party firm that conduct surveys for Fortune have slightly different set of criteria as well. For instance, the company also asked executives, directors, and analysts to rate companies in their own industry on nine criteria, from investment value to social responsibility.

How reliable are they?

When Fortune conducted its own survey using a third party firm, Hays Group, the company admitted having not covered all industries that should have been included this year. This alone could affect the over all result of its survey. Do surveys must be free from personal biases in order to be treated as having objective values? The truth of the matter is, survey questions can be biased depending on how criteria are made and how questions are being asked. Survey results are essentially the product of collective personal experiences from people or customers who have both direct and indirect contact with companies' products, services, and management. Sometimes, the reliability of a survey is measured by the credibility of the surveying firm. The more reliable the survey firm is, the more credible is the report. Or is it?

So what do you think, do the surveys represent and reflect the exact status of those companies, or would you rather have and publish your own list? You be the judge.

24 comments:

  1. APH cheaterJuly 27, 2010

    Hey Seattle Mariner, good post man, but where is RGIS in the list???? Everybody expects that it should be somewhere on top of the top ten? OK, you guys want my list of the worst companies in the face of America? Here they are:

    1. RGIS
    2. RGIS
    3. RGIS

    Sorry, I only got 3 for now.

    ReplyDelete
  2. APH cheater: As far as I know, Inventory services or similar industries were not included among the categories that Fortune or the other sites have conducted the survey. As to why, I really don't know. I think Fortune has surveyed only the top 1000 companies that have, according to respondents, voted as the least admired companies. With that criterion alone, RGIS has failed to be in that level.

    As far as the Consumerist data is concerned, I think it was the readership of the website that decided the outcome of its survey.

    Honestly, I would love to see how RGIS would be evaluated. I think www.Glassdoor.com is a good starting point. Just type RGIS from the search box and you will be amazed how the company's employees rate the company and management.

    Thanks. Happy counting.

    ReplyDelete
  3. rgis insiderAugust 04, 2010

    there are hundreds of inventory companies/services in the US alone. RGIS may be the largest inventory service in terms of global reach, BUT certainly not the best. There are few out there that deserve the title as among the best companies in the inventory class. And my company may fall under one of the least admired category. IMHO. Good post mr. mariner.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello it's me, I am also visiting this site daily, this website is really pleasant and the viewers are actually sharing fastidious thoughts.
    Also visit my weblog : Apple Valley

    ReplyDelete
  5. We are a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme
    in our community. Your website provided us with valuable info to work on.
    You have done an impressive job and our whole community
    will be grateful to you.
    Here is my weblog click through the up coming page

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi there, I discovered your site by way of Google whilst searching for a comparable topic, your website came up,
    it appears to be like great. I've bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
    Hello there, just was alert to your blog via Google, and found that it is really informative. I am gonna be careful for brussels. I will be grateful in the event you proceed this in future. A lot of folks will probably be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

    my web-site; BMW Z4 Windscreen
    Also see my website :: BMW Z4 Windscreen

    ReplyDelete
  7. Howdy just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let you
    know a few of the pictures aren't loading properly. I'm not sure
    why but I think its a linking issue. I've tried it in two different web browsers and both show the same results.

    my site st augustine mma
    my web page: phil cardella

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anyone who needs a new idea to stay motivated should definitely try this.
    Blowing off some steam with a quick round of solo travel fitness in the morning can make your
    whole day brighter. Remember; there is a difference between a fattening diet
    and a healthy diet.

    Also visit my web page: fitness tips at home

    ReplyDelete
  9. Far too many children become the victims of abuse, neglect, or abandonment and
    then sadly, often they become wards of the court who will eventually determine their fate.
    Both the content and presentation of news are drastically different from what it used to be.

    You can only visit once a day and there is no guarantee that you
    will get anything from it but as I always say, free is free.


    Here is my web blog; Latest Daily News

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hello, all the time i used to check blog posts here early in the morning, since i enjoy to gain knowledge
    of more and more.

    my homepage; http://buildyourown.co/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Far too many children become the victims of abuse, neglect, or abandonment and then
    sadly, often they become wards of the court who will eventually
    determine their fate. Both the content and presentation of news are drastically
    different from what it used to be. Due to the recent horrifying terror attacks and
    other such couple of events people want to be aware and alerted of
    the whereabouts of the nation.

    Feel free to visit my website Latest Daily News

    ReplyDelete
  12. For normal delivery the mother should be fit to cope with the delivery.
    Skiing and snowboarding are strenuous sports which demand
    a lot of endurance, so your usual set of ten to fifteen reps really
    isn''. Menopause weight gain is not inevitable, but it can be more
    difficult to maintain a healthy weight as your metabolism slows.


    Also visit my weblog - www.ultimate-wuerzburg.de

    ReplyDelete
  13. The Updated funny celebrity gossips mostly consists of on the scandals of famous or popular celebrities like James waltz
    dating with David Arquette. Every day many new websites are coming on the internet, which can be used for
    all sort of access to stuff that can make you smile.
    Many of the paintings have a tendency to use a signature in order to improve a
    funny message that's shown in the photo.

    Look into my web site ... 索引

    ReplyDelete
  14. So, if you want to get these amazing and funny gifs animated images, then what are you waiting for.
    If you have a bad dog, you can submit your story online on this submission form
    on baddogs. However, for the next several
    miles until we got to our hotel, he smelled pretty dog-gone good, not.


    Here is my weblog: http://www.istitutocesari.it/classi/user/view.php?id=12419&course=1

    ReplyDelete
  15. Helpful info. Fortunate me I found your website by accident, and I am stunned why this twist
    of fate didn't took place earlier! I bookmarked it.

    my web site :: kitchen cabinet

    ReplyDelete
  16. Bring your favorite magazines to the i - Phone with an i
    - Phone app. It’s interesting how stars get annoyed when the paparazzi takes
    pictures of them. Celebritynewsapp has developed a celebrity app which
    is getting popular day by day.

    Feel free to visit my web site: latest celeb news

    ReplyDelete
  17. Moderate to strong winds blowing from the southwest to south will prevail over northern and Central
    Luzon and coastal waters along these areas will be moderate to rough.
    We realize that we don't need to listen to outside authorities; we are not guided by our internal authority. Due to the recent horrifying terror attacks and other such couple of events people want to be aware and alerted of the whereabouts of the nation.

    Feel free to visit my site :: Latest Daily News

    ReplyDelete
  18. AnonymousMay 23, 2013

    We are a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community.
    Your web site provided us with valuable information to work on.
    You've done an impressive job and our whole community will be grateful to you.

    Also visit my web blog - Funny Videos Zor Porno

    ReplyDelete
  19. AnonymousJune 06, 2013

    Thе otheг day, ωhile I waѕ аt work, my cousin stolе my iphone
    and teѕted to see if іt can ѕurvive а 30 foot
    ԁrop, juѕt so ѕhe can be a
    yοutube sensation. My applе іpad іs now broken anԁ she has 83 views.

    Ι know thіs iѕ сompletely οff topic but I had to share it
    with sоmеone!

    Here is my site: Lloyd Irvin

    ReplyDelete
  20. AnonymousJune 07, 2013

    Thankѕ on yοur marvelous pоѕtіng!
    I quite enjoyеd reаding it, yоu wіll bе
    a grеat author.I ωill be sure tο bookmaгk your
    blog аnd ԁefinitely will comе bacκ
    at sοmе point. І want to enсouragе you to сontinue youг greаt
    ϳοb, hаѵe a nice evеning!


    Also visіt my ωеb-site: reputation management

    ReplyDelete
  21. AnonymousJune 14, 2013

    I create a leave a response each time I appreciate a post on a site or if I
    have something to contribute to the discussion.
    It's caused by the passion displayed in the article I browsed. And on this post "Top 10 most hated, and least admired US companies for 2010". I was excited enough to post a leave a responsea response :-P I do have a few questions for you if it's allright.

    Is it just me or does it give the impression like a few of these
    remarks come across as if they are left
    by brain dead folks? :-P And, if you are posting at other sites, I would
    like to follow you. Would you list all of your social pages like your
    linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?


    my web-site ... Justin Sather

    ReplyDelete
  22. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Great survey, I'm sure you're getting a great response.
    Bathroom Sink Faucets

    ReplyDelete
  24. This is just the information I am finding everywhere. Thanks for your blog, I just subscribe your blog. This is a nice blog..
    Bathroom Sink Taps

    ReplyDelete

Everyone is free to comment. Currently, comments are not moderated from this blog. However, Google SPAM and customized filtering are active for this blog. Be civil and polite when responding or placing your own.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...